Sustainable Packaging with Cory Connors presented by Atlantic Packaging
Join industry leaders, innovators, and changemakers as we explore the future of packaging through the lens of sustainability. Hosted by Cory Connors, an industry expert with over 25 years of experience, and presented by Atlantic Packaging, the leader in innovative sustainable solutions, we dive into what’s working (and what’s not) from cutting-edge materials to circular design strategies that can reduce waste and protect our planet.
Each episode blends real data, expert insights, and a dose of fun to help you stay informed and inspired. Whether you're in the packaging industry or simply passionate about sustainability, this podcast is your weekly go-to resource for making smarter, greener choices.
Sustainable Packaging with Cory Connors presented by Atlantic Packaging
What It Takes to Build a Better Recycling System | Jordan Fengel
•Cory Connors •Season 6•Episode 435
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
0:00
|
27:14
In this episode of Sustainable Packaging with Cory Connors, Jordan Fengel, President of the Carton Council, joins Cory to discuss the progress and ongoing challenges in expanding food and beverage carton recycling across North America.
Jordan shares insights from the Carton Council’s work to increase household access to recycling, its recent progress around California’s SB 343 recyclability criteria, and the role of Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) funding in improving recycling infrastructure. He also explains why consistent national standards for recyclability claims matter, how misinformation can undermine progress, and why packaging must protect products and prevent food waste while supporting circularity.
From visiting material recovery facilities (MRFs) to advocating for better recycling policy, Jordan emphasizes that no single organization can solve these challenges alone. The path forward depends on collaboration among brands, manufacturers, recyclers, policymakers, communities, and consumers.
Chapter List:
00:25 Introduction to Sustainable Packaging 00:49 Introduction and New Role at Carton Council 03:34 Progress in Carton Recycling 09:36 California's SB 343 and Its Impact 13:36 Challenges in Recycling and Consumer Education 13:51 Advocacy for Sustainable Packaging 18:08 The Role of EPR Funding 24:20 Future of Carton Recycling and Community Engagement
I'm here to help you make your packaging more sustainable! Reach out today and I'll get back to you asap.
This podcast is an independent production and the podcast production is an original work of the author. All rights of ownership and reproduction are retained—copyright 2022.
there's a lot of misinformation and disinformation, unfortunately, that works against us when and I really love the TRP saying we're all on the bend together. And it's totally true. that's we're all on the bend together. So work together, play together, like we all go to the MRFs together. Like it makes sense of like we should all just be working to improve the system. Welcome to Sustainable Packaging with Cory Connors, presented by Atlantic Packaging. I'm your host, Cory Connors. In today's episode, I connected with Jordan Finjall. He is the president of the Carton Council. We talk about some recent successes and challenges they have had and what the future looks like for carton recycling. I'd also like to thank 3M and SpecWright and Forest PKG for being our sponsors. So excited to have you on again, Jordan.~ really impressed with what you've been up to recently. And ~ welcome back to the show. Thanks, Cory. It's ~ great to be back and again once on the stage of the infamous Cory Connors show. Well, I'm honored, sir. And ~ like I said, you've been on at least once before, I think.~ well, I know at least once. And now you're ~ a new role in the industry. You're the president of the Carton Council, and this is the organization dedicated to expanding carton recycling across North America. So a very noteworthy and ~ commendable task, sir. It's it's a lot. Tell us about that. Tell us what it's like, ~ and how are things at the Carton Council these days? Yeah, things are busy, which I think as all commodities can ~ attest to in in the the light of seven states with EPR and and so on and so forth. But yeah, cartons are a fun part to work with, even though we're a very part of the small part of the overall volume of an inbound ton. We're about one percent of the stream. but yeah, cartons primarily based ~ paper-based product for food and beverage packaging, cable top aseptic. It's two formats you'll hear in the states and stuff.~ it was formed in 2009, Carton Council by TetraPak, Elopac, SIG, and now what is Novalex, but formerly it's Pactive, basically to work on carton recycling. So back in the day, we had very little household access and a low recycling rate. We started with the household access, I think around 18%, and we reached 60%, which is the FTC Green Guide's guideline of saying widely recyclable. In 2017. So we're coming up on a 10 year anniversary of that, which will be really cool.~ yeah, it is a big win. but I mean the the mission again, it's build build collection, sortation, and make sure there's in markets. And again, I think that's what most of our trade mark trade organizations are doing is is working within the value chain to make sure that the material can flow through. yeah. I I there is a little caveat that I picked up from when I was at C R A and Susan Collins, which she's awesome. With the container recycling institute there. And it was something about how is everyone learning and working within an EPR? And I it's a good note that Carton Council, coming from a lot of the members from the European workings and EPR being there for many decades, they brought what we call voluntary producer responsibility over to the US. And so I think that's a key note that ~ since the inception in 2009, we've worked on voluntary, where the producers are get together, ~ We are converters and they put a bunch of money in and they help the system improve through the funding and proactiveness. And so we're it's interesting to see this EPR mechanism slide in as the funding mechanism is going to change, but there are still forty three plus states there that we're gonna have to keep working on that don't have EPR. Long ways to go, but I think we're making progress, it sounds like. we often talk about on this show if it there's nothing really it's not a big deal if something is recyclable if it doesn't actually get recycled. And so this this progress that you and the team are making is ~ really impressive and frankly, ~ really exciting in my opinion. So I know you and I are are we enjoy this kind of positive things happening in the industry. Yeah. It's good. we all need some positive news in the light of everything. I think there's always a smear campaign against packaging for some reason. So yeah, wins are are celebrated, but I still I tell you, everyone I work with you know, pat yourselves on the back, but head down, keep forward and and the mission continues. And so we'll take the W's, but there's always gonna be some losses and and that actually turns the challenge into what I see as opportunity. So just keeps us going. That's right. Job security, right? Lots to do.~ Exactly. Well, you recently had a big win in California with the SB three forty three consort ~ the sortation threshold, saying that Cal Recycle has confirmed that food and beverage cartons meet that ~ that statute. tell us about that. That I know you spent a long time working on getting that approved.~ that was kind of a passion project for you, right? Yeah, passion project is a very nice way to describe that. It's again, it was a a challenge that we turned into basically an opportunity to highlight what the current state of carton recycling was, what industry has been doing and currently is doing, and what we plan to do. And sometimes everything that we kind of base our thoughts on and studies and other things ~ may not be the best information. And so we all need to continue to work together, right? And so 343 created a a different way to measure recyclability than than most ~ states and and organizations have ever done. That 60-60 threshold of of you had to have household access, but you also had to have the sortation of at the MRFs that serve the States recycling programs, which is defined by counties. I and again, it gets into like we've never seen this before kind of a thing. And so we had to work on, ~ the initial report came out and we didn't meet either of those thresholds. And that was a shock considering the what we considered proactive work with the advisory boards and the consultants on waste characterizations. We thought we were pretty much understood and carton recycling as we knew it and and how we have reported was It worked in California, right? And so the data should reflect that too. And so when we didn't make it, it was like, that was a shock. And I think that was 2022. So this has been a four-year basically ~ project. Long story short, we got a lot of data, FOIA and other little mechanisms that are available to everybody, and spent a lot of time and effort basically figuring out what was the gap.~ one of those was just some incorrect. Processing of information from on on the household access. So we worked with ~ RRS who does our third-party data base management, and they gave the data to CalRecycle. CalRecycle was like, hey, you we missed a million people, ~ which is about half a million households. And so that was significant, and that pushed us over 60% right there. So one problem solved. Next one is sortation. That has taken a while in the sense of it really. The questions being asked by CowRecycle is not just are you recyclable, can you go into a paper mill? But if someone puts it into their cart and it gets into a truck and it goes to a MERF, is it going to be sorted appropriately into a bale? And once it gets into that bale, is there a market for it? Once it gets to that market, is it actually yielding ~ an organ, 60% of the fiber has to be yielded for recyclability? So all sorts of stipulations and elements now that we have to look at that most people have not looked at. So it really changed the game. overall, yeah, the win was a great because we continued our work as we always have, which is working with MERFs to do grade 52. Helping that was that lodi opening of the full carton recycling facility. So now we have materials staying in California being recycled, but it also still goes ~ to Mexico and other places because it's a global economy. yeah. So we're over the mark and we got the news from Cal Recycle, which is a great thing. that's wonderful.~ and and these these materials are similar to in the the like in that cup, no that not that cup, but you're often you're often seen drinking out of a Starbucks paper cup.~ those are is that material considered the same? It's it's got a coating on it, it's ~ it's recyclable in a similar way. Similar in that the paperboard is SBS bleach and then similar in that the poly is low density polyethylene, different in that it's a single sided paper, you know, so it's a single sided cup and then ~ Cartons are double-sided, so you're gonna have the outer layer of the laminate and then your inner layer of the laminate. because as my my joke goes, good luck putting milk into a paper bag, you have to have a barrier. So ~ yeah, that's basically the difference. But in for that example, we've worked actually with the Food Service Packaging Institute, with with Natha and with Ashley on what we call, and it gets a w away from the current REMA/slash ISRI spec of grade 52, which is aseptic and gabletop cartons. So there are MERFs that do that. But since we can help with volume, since a material, going to a tissue mill or paper mill, or even a full carton recycler possibly in the near future, it can it can help with ~ expansion of recycling systems. And again, it's all alike material. And so we've done it in Detroit, Dallas. Let's see, Chicago and and I believe in Placer County as well with FCC most recently. So good collaborations in similar like materials. I will add a little caveat too that we are also founding members and and current active members of the Polycoated Paper Alliance, which is expanding that what's out there that's in mixed paper that is yielding enough fiber to qualify for responsible in markets to be recycled. called recycled. and yeah, there's a lot of work being done by industry because we're not out here just making trash. We're we're making packages that deliver products, but those products get to the consumer and we also need that package back for recycling. Mm. love that. That's exactly right. We have to make we have to ~ when I say we, ~ the packaging industry has to consider the end market when we make packaging. But like you said, we also have to consider that it performs and that it's gonna get the product there safely because that's number one. And the consumer gets gets the the advantage of a product that they that's ~ safe and healthy and and lasts enough. time on the shelf to so they can consume it. So all these things we have to do. well, that's great. And you've you've been, I know this because we've talked many times, you've been actually in the MERFs, the material recovery facilities, you know, talking to the people that recycle these things or the that recover these materials. And you've been doing the tests and I just want to commend you for that because I know that's a very laborious work and you've traveled a lot to do that. Yeah, I appreciate it. And I sorry if I just turned into Max Headroom earlier. I think I did. I was like glitching out there. So I even have ATT fiber, so we can put that on come on, ATT. actually mean for the I appreciate that. We were actually just in Brendan and I were in Michigan yesterday. There was a little LinkedIn LinkedIn post and we broke apart, I think we stopped at about seven and a half tons of material were sampled. In what's in mixed paper. And so we did it's about a dozen different Murphs and from all over regions of the US and had it shipped to Michigan State University. And we spent two and a half days knee deep in diapers and dead animals and whatever else was in these. And it was yeah, we're in there finding out. And ~ some of those bales I found more diapers than cartons. So for all those listening out there, it's we're not the problem. Right. That's a great point. Yeah. Consumers ~ need we need your help is is basically I think what what Jordan's saying is please, yeah, diapers don't go in recycling as much as we wish we could recycle those, that they're not easily Yeah, there are programs where you can recycle ~ diapers, but your your blue bin at home is not the it's not the right ~ end spot there. Well, when you're not ~ knee deep in ~ in waste, you're you're ~ oftentimes up on the hill advocating for things like the PAC Act. Do you can you talk about that and what what is it and and why does it matter for the future of sustainable packaging? Definitely. It's a good topic to bring up and and for f I suggesting for a future little episode you should have Lynn and Danielle come on from American and they could ~ share their thoughts since they're the ones that are definitely spearheading it. Spearheading it and I don't you know I don't speak for the whole coalition, but Carton Council is is definitely a supporter of it and we do go advocate for it currently on the hill.~ it creates basically that national framework for recyclable, compostable, reusable claims instead of a statewide or state yeah, statewide patchwork system that we're currently seeing, how a state we may say one thing and a different thing and a different thing. And and it's hard from the outside to see why that's a problem, but when you work in the industry, it's it's nearly impossible to create state-specific packaging. And so it really comes down to Either it's all going to be recyclable because that's what we're working on, national level recycling, which is going to filter down to the states, or a state will say you're not recyclable, but since that state says it, then all of a sudden the whole nation now becomes that package doesn't have a recyclable symbol. So it can be very impacted by one state's decision, actually at a national level. And that's the problem with this patchwork system. So it defines recyclability. gets it done through a a certified body and system. So there isn't one right now, but there is a how to recycle. There are others that have a framework built that could be ~ you know bettered to to fit the obligation necessary. and this isn't something I think that is I think people are like, this is like a brand new thing coming and it's not because about 10 years ago we saw this happen, ~ 2014, Vermont. They started with the GMO labeling, right? And it became a it was everywhere. We needed state laws on on labeling here, and some states didn't want to do it, and it became crazy. And in twenty sixteen, we had the federal law basically here. Here's how you label for GMOs. And if you go and all of look at products in your s in your shelf, you'll see it. If it has it or not, it has it, it's labeled, and no one says anything about it. But there's a federal standard standard. on how it gets applied, we want the same thing for recyclability and compostability compostability, so ~ quantifiable and verifiable and that's basically what this does again at the natural level. That's a that's such an excellent point. And it's such an important part of this process is the the end game here is is a national~ attack on this or a national system that everybody knows, everybody understands. This symbol means this or this this material means this. And I think I agree with you that eventually we'll we'll get there. because we kinda have to. It's it's it's gonna it's gonna be nearly impossible to do it state by state. successfully, ~ in my opinion, and ~ all the lawmakers I've spoken with understand that. So they're working hard to to change that. we've talked a lot about EPR, extended producer responsibility and and and what the the effect that that's gonna have on the brands and the consumers, but we haven't talked a lot about what that funding will do, what it will be used for.~ do you are you excited to to see what that ~ EPR money will be used for in the recycling systems? I am. It looks like I'm turning into Max Headrim again. So sorry.~ yeah, it it is it's it, you know, I think the funding is gonna be really cool to see come into play. And there's a great example ~ I can point to when we were in Oregon at a at a MERF and the operator was showing us the current system and they were having a lot of issues with materials like cartons, which are currently part of the Oregon program, ~ not being captured. all the way and and they have a a MERF capture ~ performance rate in Oregon for the law. So long story short, you know, the quote was we're getting an optical sorter and it's gonna help capture cartons, polypropylene, other materials. and that wouldn't be possible without EPR funding. And so that was I was like that's a billboard right there, right? So that's kind of a cool thing to right. It's kind of a cool here thing to hear. And so it that's like I was saying earlier, that's not going to stop us from the the What we do in all the other states that don't You think we were talking EPR funding? Yeah. Yeah. I wanted to talk to you about ~ your kind of your history.~ you spent a long time at at a company ~ that makes cartons. did that history kind of help you in this current role and and kind of guide your your current path? Yeah, it was it's definitely ~ being on the manufacturer side I think helped a lot of what we do and how we do it because it's the understanding of I think there's a a thought by some that a a law can be passed and like well, that's it, manufacturing's gonna change, but the the ripple effect of supply chains and retooling and all that stuff sometimes can take years ~ across to scale it, right? And it may not even be available because of tariffs and other things that that people just don't even look at.~ so yeah, but even before TetraPak, I ran a state recycling organization in Texas and and we passed a ~ know a market development bill in Texas, so Senate 649, and basically charged the state to how do we build recycling markets here? Because there's a lot of ~ mills and such, but we need more collection, so on and so forth. So kind of understood the advocacy side of it and it really comes down to economics. And does it make money, you know, save money? And that I think in overall you can talk about circularity and all of the good things and and really it is better for an economic system, which can be healthy if you do it healthily on the system, on the on ~ in the sustainability in the environment and taking materials and yeah, and the converter side is also on the like the packaging design and for recyclability and how that how does that work what after it gets to the consumer and and what are converters looking at? And so Carton council wise, now from the TetraPack side, it's it's looking at how do we recover these materials? But knowing that when a law is asking for a packaging change or a source reduction, the first, the hierarchy of a package is to make the product safe and deliver it to the consumer as intended. And so working through requirements like post consumer fiber or again source reduction and things like reducing aluminum.~ it's all being done, but the first thing is it's like they can't make the product last you know, it has to last the same time. It can't be shorter on the shelf because then you're generating food waste, right? So like what's there's not you can't trade one thing off for another thing and you have to look through those risks and benefits. So That's how it really plays in the advocacy, I think talking about things and ~ understanding from the converter side. I think it's an incredible point. We w it must perform. It has to has to work. It has to work as well, if not better, than it than it does today. Consumers expect it. They frankly deserve it, in my opinion. you know, we we need to be able to ship products around the world and have them show up on a shelf and and be safe to consume and and you know, the health and wellness of the community is is is key. I did want to talk to you about kind of the the labeling debate. Yeah. you know, there's this big debate on, well, we it should have a recycling symbol on it if it's recyclable. and but now this the new Cal these new California laws are saying, well, you can't have any recycle symbols if it doesn't get recycled in this ~ amount. And will it get to a point where people just stop putting any any labels on packaging at all?~ just as a kind of a a way to turn their back on on these you know, this ideology of of well, you can't if if we can't put this on here in some states, we're just not gonna put it on at all. And and will that actually decrease recycling?~ it's we're gonna see it play out with cartons. I can we I know that like for there are very large CPGs that that did the did the decision to to basically design 2027 artwork with no recycling logo on the carton because the legal uncertainty before we got the affirmation from Cal Recycle that we were going to get the update on the CMC coming up in January. And ~ Yeah, I think I believe there was eight or nine, and I I think they're still active but being dealt with by the individual member companies, but active lawsuits for greenwashing in California, citing 343, which still isn't law, ~ for the recycling logo. And so there's there's people out there. I I kind of worked as a paramedic as the stuff, and so there's ambulance chasers and I call them now packaging chasers. And there's people who are gonna be walking around store shelves, right, picking something up and going. is there recycling logo on this? And if it is, the biggest problem with that is as I jokingly say, the only thing with a born-on date is Budweiser. And so we're not going to be able to how are you going to tell if that was made before the October deadline date and you're not? And so when explaining all this conundrum to CalRecycle and such, it was like, well, you know, if it's all the facts play on all that stuff, you you'll it'll play out in court and you'll you won't be a problem. But and like no one wants to go to court. And so the easiest choice to your point. It's to remove the logo. And so we are going to see that ~ product wide on on multiple products in 2027 because of that decision, even though we are now, as we were confidently saying, ~ with our the some of the customers that yeah, we're gonna get it fixed. But ~ yeah, it's it's you know, I think this is interesting because you know look at it and it's like, we're only at 62%, right? And so people are like, that's that's crazy. But look at TRP's data. And I believe that and I'm not sure the most recent report, but the the previous report had about 73% of all US households have access to recycling, right? So we have 63% of that. So that means 86% of households that have a recycling cart or a drop off program can put cartons in their program. So we're nearly 90%, right? If you actually think about it. So it's in context, it's not 100% of households have recycling. So it's not that we have 62% and there's the 48% that don't, or whatever, 38% that don't. Right. Flip side. So there is a 10 percentage point gap that does exist to get to that 100%, but that's what we work on.~ decades coming up on widely recyclable for us. Hopefully, it doesn't take another 10 years before everyone consider us like a legacy material like everything else. So it's we've been around a while. Yeah, the last number I heard was fifty million US households don't have access to recycling ~ curbside. And ~ and that's a big it's a big ask to to ask a a family or you know where where they whether they live in an apartment or a rural area or, you know, to to drive their or you know, to get their recycling to a a MERF or a to a drop off location. It's It's a lot to ask when when people are busy in life and ~ working hard to to survive and to, you know, keep their their their people fed and healthy. But so I understand. I understand why there's this gap and I understand why we have a long ways to go.~ but I wanna kinda look at the the road ahead. What do you what do you see in the future for carton recycling that Maybe give us a couple of things that you think maybe are positive steps, something that people listening can work on. I yes let's I there's the overall message, right? I think is that there's a lot of work to be done, like you mentioned.~ but carton recycling is mainstream. we need to like close this gap as far as the inclusion gap that we're working with households and programmatic materials. EPR is gonna help accelerate this, but there's still a lot of work to do where EPR doesn't exist. And so I don't I think Trying to have put all your eggs in one basket that EPR is gonna either solve everything or not is it's is a gamble. And so I think people still need to engage in the infrastructure side, working with the communities, working with the Murphs, the Haulers, and your in markets, right? Everything's gotta be strong on that value chain. You have to have the policymakers understand what your value your material does. Does it, you know, extend shelf life through non-refrigeration? Yes, that's cool. Getting rid of us actually increases food waste. That's not cool. Right. And then providing the information just on a clear basis, be a resource. And I think that's there's a lot of misinformation and disinformation, unfortunately, that works against us when and I really love the TRP saying we're all on the bend together. And it's totally true. We that's we're all on the bend together. So work together, play together, like we all go to the MRFs together. Like it makes sense of like we should all just be working to improve the system. EPR is gonna help.~ it's not the silver bullet, but It's going to be very interesting to see how it rolls out in the sense of of the source reduction and all the things that people are working on in a very hurried timeline. Yeah. Well, keep up the great work, Jordan. I really appreciate your time and sharing your wisdom and all the things that you're doing for a a more sustainable future. Yeah, thanks for dealing with my technical difficulties. Thanks,